The Reading
Matrix
Vol.3, No.1, April 2003
Integrating Cultural Pluralism through
Reading
Guang-Lea
Lee
Abstract
The paper provides practical suggestions
for teachers to integrate cultural pluralism in
three reading strategies (1) reading workshops,
(2) writing workshops, and (3) language experience
approaches which make a valuable contribution
to students of all cultural backgrounds.
Introduction
America is a culturally
pluralistic society in which numerous distinct
ethnic, religious, and cultural groups coexist
within one nation. Most Americans believe people
should have the right to retain their cultural
identity as a positive expression of American
pluralistic societal ideals (Blau, 1998; King,
Chipman, & Cruz-Janzen, 1996).
Teachers have a critical role
in play to encouraging and maintaining a culturally
pluralistic society. They have an opportunity
to incorporate multicultural
activities about diverse cultures as they
organize their classroom activities. The activities
they use should reflect our nation's increasing
diversity and allow students to share their similarities,
develop a positive cultural identity, and appreciate
the unique contributions of all cultures. The
best way to incorporate multicultural literature,
depicting African-American,
Asian,
Arabic,
Native
American, and Hispanic
heritage, is to integrate it into the established
reading program rather than as a separate or distinct
area of study. This paper suggests that teachers
integrate
cultural pluralism into three reading activities
that are in widespread use--(1) reading workshops,
(2) writing workshops, and (3) language experience
approaches.
Reading Workshops
In reading
workshops, students select from a variety
of reading materials such as books, reports, biographies,
encyclopedias, and magazines. Students share their
responses to the literature by writing or talking
with teachers and classmates (Atwell, 1987). One
of the benefits of reading workshops is that it
allows students to take ownership of their reading
by choosing their own reading material. To allow
students to select from varied materials, teachers
need to have a large supply of multicultural literature
to choose from that is sensitive to and reflective
of students' diverse cultural backgrounds. When
reading these materials, students can learn that
most people have similar emotions, needs and dreams
(Bishop, 1997; Wardle, 2000). During reading workshops,
students usually engage in five activities--reading,
responding, sharing, mini-lessons, and reading
aloud.
Reading
In a reading activity,
students usually spend 30 to 60 minutes independently
reading books and other written materials that
include diverse cultures. Since these materials
play an important role in bringing cultural pluralism
into reading instruction, classrooms should have
a variety of instructional materials representing
diverse cultures such as information about African-American,
Asian, Arabic, Native American, and Hispanic students
(Hicks, 1999). For example, when students select
and read "Journey to Topaz (1971)" from
the collections of Asian literature, they not
only learn about Japanese culture but also gain
non-mainstream perspectives about Japanese-American
internment camp during World War II. Multicultural
literature, carefully integrated into the
reading workshops, enable students to maintain
their own ethnic and cultural identity among different
groups, and to accept and affirm cultural pluralism
(Bishop, 1997).
Responding
After students select
and independently read a multicultural storybook,
teachers should direct them to make inferences
and reflect on the meaning of the story in their
own lives. This encourages students to make personal
connections to stories and predict different outcomes.
In this process, students interpret meanings and
draw inferences based upon their own cultural
perspectives and experiences.
Students usually keep journals
or reading logs in which they write their
initial responses to the materials they are reading.
They may also talk with the teacher about their
books. Teachers play an important role in helping
students expand and enrich their responses to
literature (Hancock, 1993). They help students
move beyond simply writing summaries and toward
reflecting and making connections between literature
and their own lives (Barone, 1990; Kelly, 1990;
Yokota, 1995).
Sharing
Sharing racial, cultural,
and ethnic differences of diverse families heightens
a child's sensitivity to issues involving prejudice,
racism, and intolerance toward students of different
cultures. According to Becker (1979) and Banks
(1994), literature helps students develop cross-cultural
competency in cultures beyond their national boundaries
and helps them gain the insights needed to understand
the interconnectedness of all people. Exposing
students to culturally diverse literature provides
them with a means to become global citizens who
can perform more effectively in a culturally diverse
society.
Mini-Lessons
Mini-lessons provide a
teacher with a brief period of time, usually 10
to 20 minutes, to present vital reading skills
and strategies based on students' needs. To advance
cultural pluralism, a teacher can prepare a short
lesson on particular authors who write about people
with diverse cultural backgrounds. A teacher also
can teach a mini-lesson on noticing ethnic language
and creating images in their mind as they read
multicultural literature. When students are unfamiliar
with foreign settings, characters, or events in
a story, a teacher can teach them a lesson on
how to make connection to their own lives and
previously read stories.
Reading Aloud
Teachers read
aloud when they wish to present literature
that students might not be able to read themselves,
such as award-winning
books that they feel every student should
be exposed. After the teachers read to them, students
should participate in a class discussion about
the book and share the reading experience. This
activity is important because it allows students
to respond to the story together as a community
of learners, not as individuals (Tompkins, 2002).
Writing Workshops
The
writing workshop is an organized activity
for teachers to use for facilitating writing development.
During a writing workshop, it is important for
teachers to encourage students to write a story
depicting the lives of persons around the world
as they imagine a setting and characters with
foreign names (Reutzel & Cooter, 2000; Zahorik
& Novak, 1996). For example, a teacher introduces
a fairy
tale from other countries before asking children
to write a creative story. Pedro is a main character
in a Spanish version of the Cinderella story created
by a child who is seven years old: He wrote, "A
long, long time ago in Spain, there lived a child.
His name was Pedro. One day, Pedro wanted to fly
but he couldn't. He put the magic wings on he
found and they worked. Then, he went to Cantabria,
Spain and met a girl, who had magic wings too.
So, they got married and lived happily in their
little palace on a hill."
In a writing workshop, students
can make a book box containing cultural items
of a country or several countries such as ornaments,
clothing, pictures, or music tapes associated
with the story line they create. Another way of
integrating multicultural activities in writing
workshop is to involve students in a multicultural
pen-pal
project. Students can send letters about their
lives to students in a school in a foreign country
using Internet based email systems. Students can
compose group letters to partner classes in other
nations about their school, their lives, or a
favorite part of the books they have read about
the partner's country. Copies of these books and
thank you notes from partner classes can be displayed
in the school by posting them on bulletin boards.
From this activity, students learn that there
are interesting books to read from different countries
and nice kids to share ideas with all around the
world. As students engage in these writing activities,
they expand their views about other cultures by
sharing language, beliefs, religion, heritage,
and their school and home life.
Another writing workshop method
involves having students write an autobiography
containing a description and history of their
family, including pictures of the family or the
country's flag. These should be displayed around
the classroom. As a project following the writing,
students can make a story quilt illustrating the
theme of the autobiography. These activities,
which connect the reading and writing with art
projects, provide aesthetic experiences and develop
insights and awareness for different cultures
and values.
Teachers can also utilize guest
speakers available in their local area by contacting
a minority community
center. Speakers might be a director of an
international program at a local university, a
minister, and a person from the community with
knowledge of a different culture. It is useful
for the students to prepare questions in advance.
The K-W-L (What I know - What I Want to Learn
- What have I Learned) approach can be used to
make students responsible for interviewing and
searching for answers about the speaker's country
of origin. Students can also write the invitation
and follow-up letter of appreciation to the speaker.
Other creative ways for teachers
to integrate cultural pluralism in writing workshops
include:
- Ask students write a short
stories about the ethnic origins, meanings,
and backgrounds of their names or nicknames.
Have students write a poem, "my best friend
is from......" to introduce their friends'
families, interests, customs, memorable events,
and hobbies.
- Have children express their
ideas and exciting experiences in writing after
attending a cultural festival.
- Ask students to choose a favorite
culture and write about its people, tradition,
clothes, music, food, games, etc.
- After reading aloud a multicultural
book, such as "Angel Child, Dragon Child
(Surat 1983)," aloud to students, ask students
to write about the illustrations, characters,
and plot, especially describing the cultural
differences they found inspiring.
Finally, students can conduct
independent or collaborative research to learn
more about different cultures. Students can use
customary sources of data such as encyclopedia
and other reference books, but visits to foreign
countries' embassies or consulates, as well as
the Internet, are also possible sources.
Language Experience Approaches
To integrate cultural pluralism
in the Language
Experience Approach (LEA), students participate
in reading, writing, speaking, and listening activities
using personal experiences and stories written
by them based on cultural events in their own
lives. The LEA literacy learning activity is useful
because it allows students to communicate their
values, beliefs, cultures, and most of all their
own identity with others who are not familiar
with it. This activity is also beneficial for
teachers who can use the information gained to
better understand their students' cultures.
The starting point of the LEA
approach is to help students identify diverse
cultural experiences they wish to explore and
write about. Some of the idea-stimulating experiences
teachers may provide for students to be involved
include:
- Take students to various cultural
centers and ethnic festivals on field trips.
- Have students read and discuss
fiction and nonfiction about various cultural
groups.
- Encourage students to participate
at local cultural events or excursions with
their families and bring the stories of individuals
they saw to the class.
- Assist students in using the
Internet to explore various cultural groups.
- Invite guest speakers with
diverse cultural backgrounds to talk with the
students.
- Plan for a special lesson
for making
and eating foods from various countries.
- Have a brunch or tea party
while discussing various types of beverages
from around the world.
Integrating multicltural activities
through the student centered LEA approach is effective,
since students suggest the activity or topic and
provide relevant experiences for their meaningful
reading and writing activities (Tompkins, 2002).
For example, around a holiday season, students
work in pairs to discuss, write, and share with
classmates about important holidays that their
family celebrates, thus allowing the students
to learn about the diversity of holidays around
the world. These holidays might include Hanukkah
(Jewish), Kwanzaa
(African), Chinese
New Year (East Asian), Ramadan
(Moslem),
Diwali (Indian), and Chusok
(Korean). During such student-centered activities,
students will treasure and possess pride in their
own heritage.
Another way of incorporating LEA
is writing and sharing a personal journal based
on a student's daily cultural experiences at home.
For example, a six-year-old student whose parents
are Korean wrote and illustrated an "All
about Me" journal, introducing himself and
his mother: "I am Matthew, a six year old
boy. My mom is from Korea. I like to attend a
Karate class." The student drew his self-portrait
in the center of the paper as part of the journal.
These cultural journals can be shared in the classroom
on a daily basis. When students enjoy writing
and sharing about their diverse home cultures
with classmates, they will learn that people of
all cultural groups are different, but have similar
interest, needs, and life.
Conclusion
This paper reviewed how cultural
pluralism is integrated in three reading activities--reading
workshops, writing workshops, and language experience
approaches. Teachers who integrate cultural pluralism
using diverse cultural literature and activities
can make a valuable contribution to students as
they seek to establish positive perceptions about
cultural pluralism, to understand people from
other cultures, and to learn to cherish different
cultures. Cultural pluralism should be an integral
part of the curriculum that contributes to students'
reading, writing, speaking, and listening development.
It offers teachers and their students a wonderful
opportunity to assist and advance humanity by
understanding and respecting all persons on earth.
Guang-Lea
Lee is an assistant professor in
the College of Education at Old Dominion
University. She teaches both undergraduate
and graduate reading courses. Dr. Lee's
area of expertise includes emergent reading,
reading diagnosis, and multicultural education.
Email: LxLee@odu.edu |
References |